Tama Rockstar vs. Imperialstar (Spoiler: CHeaper is Better!) 

Disclosure: We may earn a commission from affiliate links on this page, at no extra cost to you. However, all our opinions are our own.

  • The Tama Rockstar and Imperialstar are both solid sets. But which one do you actually need for your setup?!
  • I put these two kits head-to-head to see which one was better
  • Also, check out our Tama vs. Pearl vs. Mapex comparison!

I remember the first time I tried out the drums- I was on a half-dilapidated kit in my friend’s basement… But something about banging on an instrument was so freeing and wild. I quickly learned I had a passion for classical flute and rock drumming. But then there was the question of what kind of kit to get. So, let’s take a look at these two beginner kits. 

I recently visited the Sweetwater storefront in Indiana and tried out a bunch of sets, including ones by Tama. In this article, I will share my thoughts on these two kits by the same maker and help you pick the best for you.

TAMA Rockstar Vs. ImperialStar

QUick Summary

The Tama Rockstar and Tama Imperialstar are two popular entry-level drumsets worth considering. But even though it’s way cheaper, the Tama Rockstar is a better drumset than the ImperialStar. I will cover this in detail throughout the rest of the article.

While it’s easy to definitively say that the Rockstar is a better kit, which one you buy depends on what you’re looking for and how much research you’re willing to do.

Some folks want to hand-pick their kits- The Rockstar allows for that. This means you won’t be stuck with extra cymbals and other accessories you don’t need.

But if you are starting from scratch, you might want to get the Imperialstar, take the time to learn more about drums, and come back for an upgraded, more custom kit later.

Comparison

Tama RockstarTama Imperialstar
Number of Pieces55
ShellsBirch, BasswoodPoplar
Wood Ply6-ply, 7-ply bass drum6 ply
EdgesHeavy and sturdy (Precision edges)Heavy and sturdy (Also Precision)
CymbalsNot includedIncluded
Hi-hatXMeinl HCS 14″
CrashX16″
RideX20″
Toms2 mounted, 1 floor2 mounted, 1 floor
PedalSingle-chain drive w/bass plateSingle-chain drive w/plate
WrapsGlued, covered finishGlued
Hardware TypeHardware not includedBlack nickel
StandsNoneBoom, straight, hi-hat
Tom HoldersModular tom mountOmnisphere, L-Rod
ThroneNoYes
Price$499.99$899.99
Tama Rockstar vs Imperialstar

Key Differences

The Imperialstar and Rockstar are entry-level instruments, with the Rockstar being one notch closer to intermediate than the ImperialStar. The ImperialStar is still a stellar kit that will serve you well as a beginner. 

Despite being ‘-Star’ made from the same brand, these two Tama sets are very distinct. The shells are made of different kinds of wood, separate brands make the stock heads, and the hardware and accessories are different as a whole.

Material & Tone 

One of the biggest factors that jumped out to me with these two models is the difference in shells. The lower-level Imperialstar has poplar shells, whereas the Rockstar has birch. Poplar shells have quite a bit of controversy surrounding them. Birch, on the other hand, is generally thought of as higher quality.

Despite the Imperialstar featuring 6-ply, Poplar will always be a ‘cheap wood’ in the drum world. The Rockstar also has some basswood in the mix- basswood is a type of soft linden wood. Lindens are often used to make high-quality guitars, recorders, and sometimes drums.  

Cymbals 

The ImperialStar has the HCS cymbal pack by Meinl. HCS cymbals are made from a bronze alloy and are standard, clear-sounding instruments. If you are looking for a darker sound, Zildjans would be a better bet. But these Meinls sounded nice to me, especially at this price point. With the Rockstar, again, all the accessories are up to you. 

Precision Edges 

Both kits feature Tama’s signature precision bearing edges. If you’re a drum newbie, learning about bearing edges is essential. ‘Precision bearing edges’ is Tama’s code for ‘we added metal rings, so it’s harder!”. That’s a good thing, especially if you’re a heavy-handed player. 

Accessories and Hardware

The ImperialStar has a bass pedal, cymbals pedal, and throne — just add drumsticks! On the other hand, the Rockstar only comes with the bass pedal—no throne or anything else. The Imperialstar also has stands with double-leg bracing, resulting in a very study setup. As for the Tama Rockstar, the drums are sonically better, but you’ll have to buy most all the doo-dads separately.

Bass Pedals 

Most Imperialstar and Rockstar packages have a single-chain drive with the bass plate. Let me translate that into English: there are many ways to build a bass drum pedal, but these have just one chain connecting the apparatus. Double-chain pedals are generally sturdier and more accurate than single-chain ones, so consider an upgrade eventually. 

Overall, both the Tama Imperialstar and Tama Rockstar drum kits are high-quality options well-suited for the needs of different drummers. The Imperialstar kit is an excellent choice for beginner to lower intermediate drummers who want a reliable and versatile kit, while the Rockstar kit is a notch above in both build and sound quality (but doesn’t have everything you need inside of one package). 

Alternatives To Consider

Rockstar production stopped around 2018-2019, but you can still get one online at Guitar Center. Aside from the Imperialstar, here are some other Tama models to check out: 

  • Tama Silver Star
  • Tama Clubjam 
  • Tama Superstars 

The Silver Star is a 4-piece birch kit that packs a punch and usually costs about $799.99. The Clubjam, on the other hand, is a vintage-style Mini kit with poplar shells. It costs just over $500 and is perfect for those who want to stick to the basics.

Their Superstar Classic and Hyperdrive are great options but are much higher quality and more expensive. Pearl’s Decade kit is also a good contender here, but it doesn’t come with cymbals, so you’ll have to consider that. 

The Superstar Classic is a Tama kit that really struck me (get it?!) when I tried it. I quickly fell in love with the aesthetic, customizable maple shell (I was playing on one with a gorgeous gradient), the uber-sturdy hardware, and the fine-tuned feel.

FAQ 

How Reliable is the Tama Brand? 

Tama’s drums are generally reliable, whether from the entry-level line or above. Tama (originally Star Drums) has been around since the 1960s. Their kits started as economical entry-level sets, but as the company grew, they expanded into intermediate and pro territory.

Tama drums from the 1970s and forward are of a higher caliber than what was initially produced. That’s all to say that the Tama brand is well-known and high-quality.

How is It That the Rockstar is Better and Cheaper?

Tama likely left out the hardware and cymbals so that they could make a more economical kit of higher quality. This is likely how the company could afford to use wood superior to Imperialstar’s and still charge less. I wish the Rockstar had a throne and a double bass pedal- But a girl can dream, right? 

What Are Poplar Shells Good For?

Some people might say they’re good for nothing! Jokes aside, I’d say, if you’re going to go for a Poplar shell kit, just make sure it has a decent amount of layers (6 or 7). Poplar is known for sounding warm/bright and is a very soft wood.

To me, poplar toms sound much more sonically flat than something like maple, but to each his own. Tama’s drool-worthy precision edges help the polar shells sound a bit more…sparkly!

What is the Most Basic/Entry Level Tama Set?

Tama’s Rhythm Mate drum kit is a basic, entry-level kit. It has many convenient features, like double-braced stands and a drum beater angle adjustment on the bass drum. The Tama’s Swingstar is another entry-level option you’ll read about here on the web, but it’s no longer being produced.

Disclosure: Enjoyed the read and want to support an independent publication? Head to our store and pick up an attractive art print, mousepad or sample pack to help us keep the lights on! We may also earn a commission from affiliate links on this page too. Thank you for your support.
Avatar photo
Aleah Fitzwater

A multi-instrumentalist and freelance music critic/ writer and journalist from the Toledo, Ohio area. She holds a BE in instrumental music education, and has recorded with renowned Indie-artist Amarante in Creatures of the Cosmos. She currently writes for Yamaha’s Educator Suite, and teaches classical flute in her home studio. When she’s not writing or making music, you can find her creating art, reading fantasy novels, or growing bizarre vegetables in the garden.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *